Tuesday , January 18 2022
Home / world wide / Harry Potter: 6 Instances Of Foreshadowing In the First Book (That Didn’t Make The Movies)

Harry Potter: 6 Instances Of Foreshadowing In the First Book (That Didn’t Make The Movies)

There was a lot left out of the movie version of The Philosopher’s Stone – including these moments of foreshadowing.

It’s no secret that when J K Rowling was working on the Harry Potter series, she planned things out extremely carefully, laying the groundwork for future reveals from the very first pages of Harry Potter And The Philosopher’s Stone. Throughout the first book, there are layers of meaning – like in Snape’s potion class, when he asks Harry about specific ingredients – and moments of foreshadowing.

6 Dumbledore’s Watch

In the same scene that Dumbledore expresses a love of muggle sweets, he is also described as checking his watch, which “had twelve hands, but no numbers, with little planets moving around the edge”. This is later revealed to be, presumably, a watch given to Dumbledore when he came of age – as Molly gives one to Harry, and explains that a gift of a gold watch is a wizarding tradition.

Like his love of Lemon Drops, though, this is a tiny detail that would easily be left out of the film with no major repercussions – especially as the first film was made in 2001, and the scene where this tradition was explained wasn’t until the Deathly Hallows – which was released as a book in 2007! There was no way to know that this was anything but a casual detail to make things more magical.

5 Neville’s Broken Wrist

In both the book and film, Neville falls off his broom in class, and breaks his wrist – leading Madam Hooch to leave with him, Harry to fly after the Remembrall, and get picked for the Quidditch team. In the film, that’s the last heard of Neville’s injury, but in the book, Harry meets him later, and is told that the nurse fixed it “in about a minute”. This comes into play later, when Harry is injured, and ends up having to regrow bones, because Professor Lockhart tried to fix it!

This isn’t a major change, but it is interesting to realize that Harry, and everyone else in his class, knew without a doubt how easy it was for Madam Pomfrey to fix bones. This then adds to the distrust and dislike of Lockhart, as they would have known just how badly he messed up the spell.

4 How Old Scabbers Is

In both the book and the film, Ron introduces Harry to Scabbers, and makes a comment about how unimpressed he is with his pet. However, in the book, he is talking about getting hand-me-downs, and says explicitly that Scabbers is an ‘old’ rat that was given to him by his older brother.

10 Harry Potter Characters With The Most Total Movie Screentime

Of course, this is a huge plot point later on, as it’s revealed that Scabbers is Peter Pettigrew in his Animagus form! In the film, there is no hint that Scabbers is any other than a normal rat, which actually lessens the impact of the moment when the truth comes to light.

3 Flamel On The Chocolate Frog Card

In the books, Harry first hears the name of Nicholas Flamel when he’s reading the back of his first Chocolate Frog card. The Dumbledore card includes the notes that he is known for his work with the uses of dragon’s blood, and “his work on alchemy with his partner, Nicholas Flamel”. Harry later knows he has heard the name somewhere, but can’t place it – until he eats another Chocolate Frog and remembers. In the movie, Hermione finds the same info in a book.

This is a much bigger change, and one that really puts the emphasis on Hermione, and her ability to figure things out. This is an understandable change, in many ways – it makes Hermione the hero, and ensures that no fan wonders why Harry wouldn’t remember this in the first place.

2 The Motorbike Belonging To Sirius

In the opening scene, Hagrid flies down on a giant motorbike, carrying Harry. In the book, Hagrid explains that he borrowed the bike from Sirius Black, and when he leaves, he says that he should be getting it back to him. This, of course, foreshadows Black’s role – and the big reveal in The Prisoner of Azkaban that Sirius was actually a friend to the Potters!

This may have been left out specifically to enhance the shock of that reveal – and, of course, because it doesn’t initially matter how Hagrid got the bike.

1 Dragons At Gringotts (& Hagrid Wants One)

One of the key plot points in the first installment in the series is that Hagrid has set Fluffy, his three-headed dog, to guard the Stone… and that he accidentally tells someone how to get past Fluffy when convincing the stranger to give him a dragon egg. He’s always wanted a dragon, and Harry eventually figures out that the one he gets was a setup.

In both book and movie, Harry tells Hermione and Ron that Hagrid has always wanted a dragon, and that he told Harry as much when they first met. In the book, this is true – Hagrid mentions that there are said to be dragons at Gringotts, and that he’s wanted one since he was a kid. In the film, however, Hagrid never actually tells Harry this at all! This was an oversight, as a deleted scene shows the two on the tube, where Hagrid says he wants a dragon. Obviously, this was intended to be a part of the final film, but when it was removed, the plot hole this causes wasn’t resolved!

50% LikesVS
50% Dislikes

About admin

Check Also

“Lock & Key”Comics Anthology By Spains Best Female Creators Gets English Translation

Voices That Count a Spanish anthology featuring stories by women discussing their struggles and victories …

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *